
Originally Posted by
Dr. Dave in da house
I'm with the "ditch her" voting group. When you're in your 20's, you see your friends at a lot of weddings. When you're in your late 30's/early 40's, you see them as you stay on each others' couches through divorces.
In that time of life, a phrase comes up, both in reference to relationships past, and dating present: "staying with a woman longer than you should." Near every guy has done it, whether it was staying with the wife for 15 years and the last 14 were miserable with no excuse NOT to leave, or becoming a steady beau for a lass that doesn't really light your fire, but you're either emotionally addicted, or don't have much else going on to pass the time so why not.
And humans have a tendency to be a bit like apes in a tree, not letting go of one branch until they get hold of another. She's fighting with the new boy toy, but doesn't want to let it go until she has the next branch figured out....you. If you answer, "Done with you, babe.", I'll bet you 20 bucks she finds a way to make it work with the new guy. If you leave the door open for her return, she'll call the new guy and tell him they're done...but it won't last, because you'll have compromised your terms around your personhood to take her back under these circumstances, and a woman won't love a man she can't trust, and she won't trust a man who compromises his terms. Even if she's the one who tested you into compromising them. And if she meets a guy #3 in the interim that she views as a trade up, she'll drop both of you. I wish I could say this was a chick thing, but a lot of the dudes I know do it too.
Grab your nuts, get the broom & sweep her out the door, lock it, weld it shut, move on, process the pain by bitchin' about it with your bro's, and don't look back; it's emotional poison -- you cannot get where you're going looking in the rear-view mirror.
And trust me on this one: You will be a different person 5 years from now than you are today. Youth brings rapid change with aging. It also brings an emotional impetuosity that makes things hurt more and seem bigger...break-ups at 25 cut more deeply than break-ups at 35, and so on. If you stick with her now to ease the pain of absence, you'll still have to deal with splitting a couple years from now, and will be peaved about blowing the time in between. You will both be different people, grown apart.
"You must leave her, brother" -- Sean Connery/Ramirez, Highlander